Overheads, Week 6

Lecture 11 (TNK 332-373)

Contributory Negligence

 (March v Stramare (TNK 311))

Thompson v Commissioner for Railways (1863) 2 SCR (L) 292

redfernsmall

The old Redfern station (1855-1906)

Podrebersek v AIS (TNK 334)

Astley v Austrust (TNK 337) (no apportionment for contributory negligence when suing in contract law)

(Hawkins v Clayton (TNK 289)

(NSW) Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1965, s 8:

"wrong means an act or omission that: (a) gives rise to a liability in tort in respect of which a defence of contributory negligence is available at common law, or (b) amounts to a breach of a contractual duty of care that is concurrent and co-extensive with a duty of care in tort." Over-rules Astley v Austrust, at least where there is concurrent liability in contract and tort

Pilmer v Duke Group (High Court, 31 May 2001) (No apportionment for contributory fault in equitable compensation)

Remoteness of damage

(Doyle v Olby (TNK 47))

Hadley v Baxendale (TNK 400) (the remoteness test in contract cases: in contemplation of the parties)

pickfords

P Atiyah, The Rise and Fall of Freedom of Contract (1979)

F Faust, "Hadley v Baxendale: an Understandable Miscarriage of Justice" (1994) 15 Journal of Legal History 41

Girard v Biddulph (1834) www.law.mq.edu.au/scnsw

Kercher, "Colonial Contracts and Expectation Damages: Girard v Biddulph, New South Wales Supreme Court, 1834" (2001) 1 Macquarie Law Journal 103

Victoria Laundry v Newman Industries (TNK 354)

Koufos v Czarnikow (Heron II) (TNK 356)

Amann Aviation (TNK at 224))

Wagonmound 1 (TNK 360)

(Hughes v Lord Advocate (TNK 362))

Mayfair v Pears (TNK 365)

Parsons v Uttley Ingham (TNK 370)

Lecture 12

Final factors in assessment of compensatory damages

(TNK 373-420)

 

Mitigation

British Westinghouse v Underground Electric (TNK 374) (the test of mitigation in English and Australian law)

underground

Hoad v Scone Motors TNK 378

White and Carter v McGregor (TNK 380)

Glavonjic v Foster (TNK 384)

 

Inflation

 

(Pennant Hills Restaurants v Barrell Insurances (1981) 145 CLR 625)

Todorovic v Waller (TNK 386)

 

Taxation

Gill v Australian Wheat Board (TNK 392)

Cullen v Trappell (TNK 394)

 

Choice of factors

Burns v MAN (TNK 395)

The Borag (TNK 397)

 

Interest on damages

 

Ruby v Marsh (TNK 403)

Haines v Bendall (TNK 404)

Cullen v Trappell (TNK 408)

MBP v Gogic (TNK 411)

Hungerfords v Walker (TNK 414)